Layer

NameMiwatj Wars and Resistance (North-East Arnhem Land)
Description

Country/People

Yolŋu peoples of Miwatj (north-east Arnhem Land), including Gupapuyŋu and associated clan groups referenced in Milingimbi literature records.

Listen/Read

Narrative

In north‑east Arnhem Land (Miwatj), Yolŋu peoples maintained law, authority, and control of their Country well into the twentieth century. This of course must be seen against the backdrop of a literal millenia of trade with Macassans, and a strong intra-cultural identity of protecting trading ports and access to Macassan goods. Increasing maritime and onshore incursions by balanda (non- Yolŋu, from Hollander) — particularly fishing crews and police patrols — intensified tensions during the early decades of the 1900s.

The history of conflict in Miwatj (north-east Arnhem Land) in the early twentieth century is best understood first through Yolŋu records, and only second through colonial archives. Long before the High Court case of Tuckiar v The King (1934) entered the written legal record, Yolŋu people were documenting encounters, fights, and armed resistance in their own languages, through story, kinship memory, illustration, and place-based narrative.

One such account is “They Speared Mr Robertson,” told by Djan'palil and preserved through the Milingimbi Literature Production Centre. The story recounts a church service at Miliŋinbi during which a missionary, Mr Robertson, was speared by men who had travelled from the mainland. Yolŋu men responded by taking up guns and pursuing the attackers across floodplains and into the mangroves, before police later removed prisoners to Darwin. The narrative preserves Yolŋu names, clan identities, and specific places such as Djerrgi and Dhäbiḻa. It records not only the spearing, but the pursuit, the exchange of weapons, and the arrival of police. It is a Yolŋu-centred record of armed confrontation.

Another Yolŋu account, “A Stockman came upon Birriwun and Dhawuḻmurr,” told by Yäŋuba and preserved in bilingual form at Milingimbi (Djan'palil, 2025), describes an encounter between two Yolŋu men gathering food on Country and an armed horseman (Yäŋuba, 2025). In this story, the stockman draws his gun; the men wait with their spears. Shots are fired. The Yolŋu men drop to the ground to avoid bullets, then rise and return fire with spears. The fight continues until ammunition and weapons are exhausted. The account includes tactical description: movement across water, climbing rocky outcrops, striking the horse, and protecting a child who had witnessed the encounter. The story does not present Yolŋu as passive victims but as fighters defending themselves and their Country. These Yolŋu narratives demonstrate that Miwatj was a site of sustained armed contest. Spears and firearms appear together. Horsemen, missionaries, police, and stockmen enter Yolŋu Country and are met with resistance. Conflict is embedded within kinship structures and Country. It is remembered in language, in place names, and in family connections.

Within this broader Yolŋu-recorded history sits the Caledon Bay / Woodah Island crisis of 1932–1934. In August 1933, Yolŋu leader Dhakiyarr Wirrpanda fatally speared Northern Territory police officer Constable Albert McColl at Woodah Island (Guwanŋarripa). McColl had held Yolnu women captive. Colonial records describe the event as murder; Yolŋu memory situates it within coercive incursions and defence of family and land. Northern Territory officials considered organising a heavily armed “punitive expedition” into Arnhem Land. Public protest in southern cities ultimately prevented such an expedition from proceeding.

Dhakiyarr was arrested and tried. His conviction was quashed by the High Court in Tuckiar v The King (1934), due to serious miscarriages of justice. Shortly after his release, he disappeared while attempting to return home. In colonial archives, this case appears as a landmark legal decision. In Yolŋu history, it is one moment in a longer struggle over authority, law, and survival on Country.

This history is all the more remarkable because it forms part of the backdrop to events less than a decade later, during the Second World War, when many Yolŋu men would serve in the Northern Territory Special Reconnaissance Unit (NTSRU). The same region that colonial officials had contemplated entering with a “punitive expedition” in 1933 became, in the 1940s, strategically vital terrain to be defended against Japanese invasion (White et al, 2026). Yolŋu knowledge of sea routes, coastlines, seasonal movement, and inland tracks — the very knowledge that had sustained resistance and autonomy in earlier decades — became essential to Australia’s wartime defence. Men whose fathers and uncles had fought stockmen, police parties, and armed riders were now recruited, albeit often without formal recognition or equal pay, to patrol the coastline and monitor enemy movement (Baker, 2024).

Seen together, the Milingimbi confrontation, the stockman encounter, and the Caledon Bay crisis form part of a wider pattern of armed colonial conflict in Miwatj. The High Court trial is an intersection with written colonial records; the deeper history is preserved in Yolŋu storytelling traditions. These accounts show organised resistance, tactical adaptation, and defence of kin and land. They represent some of the final documented episodes of frontier-style armed conflict in Australia, remembered not only in court reports, but in Yolŋu language and art.

Contributor: Dr Samuel White

  •  Djan'palil. (1978/2025). Mr Robertson was Speared (W. Warrkmanydjun, Trans.). Milingimbi Literature Production Centre. https://australianwars.net/files/2512/WhenMrRobertsonWasSpeared.pdf
  • Yäŋuba. (1983/2025). A stockman came upon Birriwun and Dhawuḻmurr (W. Warrkmanydjun, Trans.). Milingimbi Literature Production Centre. https://australianwars.net/files/2512/BirriwunDhawulmurrAndTheStockman.pdf
  • Gibson, P. (2024). 'The communist-led campaign to stop a “punitive expedition” in Arnhem Land in 1933'. Labour History, (126).
  • Gibson, P. ‘Preventing the Punitive Expedition Planned in Arnhem Land’ in Spearim Boe 1933 in Frontier War Stories, 13 June 2020 (podcast) https://open.spotify.com/episode/2IcDiFPzV2qWJXqqTUUDPx
  • High Court of Australia. (1934). Tuckiar v The King (1934) 52 CLR 335.
  • White, S; Munyarryun, T; Jones, N; Daymirringu, N. Miringu Dhawu (2026, Melbourne University Press)
  • Baker, Gwenda. The Peacemakers: Three Wangurri Brothers — Warriors, Mediators & Peacemakers in Yolngu Land (Arnhem Land). Casuarina, NT: Historical Society of the Northern Territory, 2024. ISBN: 978-0646702292
TypeOther
Content Warning

Colonial violence. Historical reference may contain racist language and attitudes of the time.

ContributorDr Bill Pascoe
Entries7
Allow ANPS? No
Added to System2025-08-11 14:47:17
Updated in System2026-02-28 17:27:13
Subject Australian Wars, Aboriginal, History, Colonial Violence, Yolngu
CreatorSamuel White
PublisherAustralian Wars and Resistance
Contact
Citation
DOI
Source URL
Linkbackhttps://australianwars.net/details.php?id=2512
Date From1820
Date To1934
Image
Latitude From
Longitude From
Latitude To
Longitude To
LanguageEN
License
Usage Rights
Date Created (externally)

Blue Mud Bay

Type
Event

Details

Latitude
-13.341
Longitude
135.866
Start Date
1875-08-08
End Date
1875-08-09

Description

The NTTG reported on 30 October 1875 (p 1), that Tom Walker and his gold prospecting party left Union Camp on 1 June 1875. The Government provided five horses (of 15) and three months' provisions. At 11pm on 17 June, an Aboriginal group surprised the camp and wounded Charles Bridson. On 7 August the party reached Blue Mud Bay and on 9 August, Aboriginal people, who they thought had been friendly, attacked the camp, striking Walker, who died the next day, and David Marshall, who was severely wounded. The attacks were kept up for the ensuing nights, including attempts to burn the camp out. By the time the government cargo vessel Woolner from Port Darwin reached Union Camp at Blue Mud Bay on 21 October with a party of more prospectors, more than 40 Aboriginal people had been killed. Marshall and Bridson recovered. Four government horses were lost. No gold was ever found (Reid, 1990, p 69; NTTG 18 Dec 1875, pp 1-2). Roberts (2009, np) noted the blood lust from the Northern Territory Times and Gazette in response: "Shoot those you cannot get at and hang those that you do catch on the nearest tree as an example to the rest".

Extended Data

Source_ID
699
LanguageGroup
Yolngu
Colony
SA
StateOrTerritory
NT
PoliceDistrict
Port Darwin
Victims
Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander People
VictimsDead
40
VictimDescription
Warrior(s)
Attackers
Colonists
AttackersDead
1
AttackerDescription
Explorer(s)
CorroborationRating
***
War
Yolngu
Stage
Early
Region
North
Period
North

Sources

TLCMap ID
te1734
Linkback
https://c21ch.newcastle.edu.au/colonialmassacres/detail.php?r=699
Source
NTTG, 30 October, 1875, p1. http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article3144523; NTTG, 18 December, 1875, p. 1 https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/3144651; Reid, 1990; Macknight, 1981; Roberts, 2005, pp 120-121; Roberts, 2009, np.
Created At
2025-08-11 14:47:26
Updated At
2025-08-11 14:47:26

Details

Latitude
-12.486
Longitude
134.935
Start Date
1885-01-01
End Date
1885-12-31

Description

Gwenda Baker (2018, p 8) recorded the pastoral history of this area: 'The cattle station people arrived in 1885. They were antagonistic towards the Yolngu from the start. Macartney and Mayne set up Florida Station near the present day town of Ramingining. When some Yolngu killed a cow for food, the station owners killed a group of Yolngu with poisoned horsemeat. This started a guerrilla war by the Yolngu. The station workers had guns. Yolngu had spears and knowledge of fire and the country. Yolngu killed station workers and drove off the cattle. By 1893 it was all over. The station was abandoned and the remaining cattle moved south to another location.'
Trudgen wrote (2000, pp 19-20): '... some months later the pastoralists came with one of their wagons, offering horsemeat to many of the clans... That evening they ate, thanking the pastoralists for their good gifts. It was only when some of the people became violently ill that the Yolngu realised the Balanda had tricked them with some strange sorcery... Members of many clans died that day... Yolngu struck back, fighting with spears against muskets and carbines. Soon the skirmishes became running battles'. Men, women and children were killed by the poisoning.
The estimate of 40 killed is for the poisoning incident only. Many more would have been killed in the ongoing conflict.

Extended Data

Source_ID
748
LanguageGroup
Yolngu, Djinang
Colony
SA
StateOrTerritory
NT
PoliceDistrict
Palmerston (no police presence in Arnhem Land at that time)
Victims
Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander People
VictimsDead
40
VictimDescription
Warrior(s)
Attackers
Colonists
AttackersDead
0
AttackerDescription
Manager(s)
CorroborationRating
**
AboriginalPlaceName
Murwangi
War
Yolngu
Stage
Mid
Region
North
Period
North

Sources

TLCMap ID
te1735
Linkback
https://c21ch.newcastle.edu.au/colonialmassacres/detail.php?r=748
Source
Baker 2018, p 8; Trudgen 2000, pp 19-20.
Created At
2025-08-11 14:47:26
Updated At
2025-08-11 14:47:26

Details

Latitude
-12.104
Longitude
134.911
Start Date
1889-01-01
End Date
1896-12-31

Description

Read and Read (1991, p 24) printed a story of a massacre at Mirki as told by an anonymous person at Milingimbi, trancribed from Gupapuyngu:
Aboriginal people from a camp at Mirki were killing cattle on Florida Station, near Milingimbi. After confessing to cattle killing, an Aboriginal person was murdered. Attempting a surprise night attack on people singing and dancing at a ceremony, the colonists left their horses and surrounded them. But Aboriginal lookouts saw the horses and, thinking they couldn't escape without being seen, hid in the trees. 'Into a tree they climbed, all of them. They sat there, they didn't say anything, nothing. They were very careful for each other' (Read & Read, 1991, p 22). The colonists saw them in the trees and opened fire. 'Think about the noise that those guns made, shooting up into the trees. Shooting, shooting, shooting, up in to the trees. They all fell down into the ground, and just lay there all over the ground, every one of them, until they were all dead. But one of them was still alive. The horses had passed him on the way there. He saw them, and he hid in the cycad palms, underneath them' (Read & Read, 1991, p 22). The following day the 'boss' of the colonists took a repeating rifle, found the children, formed them into two lines and shot them. 'Every one of them, just lying there, and not only a few, lots of them' (Read & Read, 1991, p 24).
Gaunt said that Jack Waston was in that area at that time, along with Joe Bradshaw and others, 'Before closing this article I wish to say soon after Jack Watson left Florida Station he was at the Katherine' and indicated that shooting Aboriginal people was common, 'The shooting of blacks in the early days was necessary to the men who opened up the country. Self-preservation is the first law of nature and with very little police protection we had to take the law in our own hands, or be massacred in cold blood by the abos' (Northern Standard July 10, 1934, p 6).

Extended Data

Source_ID
713
LanguageGroup
Yolngu, Djinang
Colony
SA
StateOrTerritory
NT
PoliceDistrict
Port Darwin
Victims
Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander People
VictimsDead
40
Attackers
Colonists
AttackersDead
0
AttackerDescription
Pastoralist(s)
CorroborationRating
**
AboriginalPlaceName
Mirki
War
Yolngu
Stage
Mid
Region
North
Period
North

Sources

TLCMap ID
te1736
Linkback
https://c21ch.newcastle.edu.au/colonialmassacres/detail.php?r=713
Source
Read and Read, 1991, p 24; Gaunt 1934, 'Old Time Memories, The Lepers of Arnheim [sic] Land and Sketches' Northern Standard July 10, 1934, p 6 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article48064622; van der Heide, 1985, p 16.
Created At
2025-08-11 14:47:26
Updated At
2025-08-11 14:47:26

Arafura Station

Type
Event

Details

Latitude
-12.461
Longitude
134.984
Start Date
1903-01-01
End Date
1908-07-30

Description

In colonial pastoral terms, Arnhem Land was dominated by Florida Station (1884-1893) leased by John Arthur Macartney (of Macartney & Mayne fame) after which some of the same land became incorporated into Florida Station (1903-1908) leased by the Eastern and African Cold Storage Company. Generally, the area was known as Murwangi to Yolngu people.
When Arafura Station was owned by Eastern & African Cold Storage Co, the company employed groups to ride around shooting Aboriginal people. Merlan (1978, p 87) wrote that 'This was probably one of the few authenticated instances in which the aborigines were systematically hunted. For a time the company employed 2 gangs of 10 to 14 blacks headed by a white man or half caste to hunt and shoot the wild blacks on sight. When interviewed in 1957 George Conway mentioned that he had been hired to lead a hunting expedition into Arnhem Land in 1905 or 1906, and that his party had killed dozens of Aborigines.'
According to Dewar's research (1995, p 9): 'A further attempt was made to develop a pastoral industry when Arafura Station was taken up by the African Cold Storage Supply Company in 1903 in central Arnhem Land. Arafura Station was not a commercial success (Bauer 1964, 157) and the company was liquidated in 1908. The station is remembered today for the extreme violence of its managers. Accounts have been collected from both Yolngu and non-Aboriginals who remember the massacres of Yolngu in the area (Bauer 1964, 157; Dreyfus & Dhulumburrk 1980, 19-20; Read and Read 1991, 19-24; Van der Heide 1985, 15, 16, 52, 53).'
Jack 'the Gulf Hero' Watson was a Manager of Florida Station. He had been at Lawn Hill in Queensland as an employee of Frank Hann and was notorious for killing Aboriginal people, such as at the Skeleton Creek massacre.
In addition to Conway and others, Joe Bradshaw was employed at Arafura by the Eastern & African Cold Storage Co. Joe Bradshaw was the general manager for a time (Northern Territory Times and Gazette, 17 March 1905, p 3) and spent many years in the Victoria River Downs area, including on Bradshaw Station, where there were many massacres.
According to C.E. Gaunt, Jack Watson was responsible for killing many people while he was on Florida: 'After the Randalls left, Jack Watson "The Gulf Hero," as he was known to old timers, took charge and became manager... To return to Florida, when managing that place when the abos. stepped over the line, Watson threw the lead at them, and threw it to kill. He had the blacks of Blue Mud and Caledon Bays good hombres, but he had to wipe out a lot to make them so. In all the early days of Florida there was not a white man attacked or killed by blacks. The men of Florida knew how to handle blacks and then the Missionary came on the scene and made a rascal out of the abo. Then the trouble and killing of whites started. This is cold facts. Eventually Florida Station was abandoned, the chief cause being loss of stock by blacks. This was after Watson left' (Northern Standard, 6 Jul 1934, p 4).
It is difficult to isolate individual incidents, but Conway said that he killed dozens during only one expedition of one of the two gangs mentioned. In a quote relating to an expedition through Yolngu country to Caledon Bay, Conway notes that Yolngu camps were very large 'Some of their camps contained two or three thousand people' (Willey, 1964, p 103). It is reasonable to think at least 200 people were massacred by the killing 'gangs' at Florida and Arafura under Conway, Bradshaw and Watson.

Extended Data

Source_ID
1056
LanguageGroup
Yolngu, Djinang
Colony
SA
StateOrTerritory
NT
PoliceDistrict
Port Darwin
Victims
Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander People
VictimsDead
200
VictimDescription
Aboriginal
Attackers
Colonists
AttackersDead
0
AttackerDescription
Stockmen/Drover(s), Pastoralist(s)
CorroborationRating
**
AboriginalPlaceName
Murwangi or Murruwangi
War
Yolngu
Stage
Late
Region
North
Period
Late

Sources

TLCMap ID
te1737
Linkback
https://c21ch.newcastle.edu.au/colonialmassacres/detail.php?r=1056
Source
Merlan, 1978, pp 87-88; Dewar, 1992, p 9; Northern Standard, 6 Jul 1934, p 4 https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/48064516; Northern Territory Times and Gazette, 17 March 1905, p 3 https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/4328639/828514; Willey, K, 1964, p 103; Olney J, 2003, p 47.
Created At
2025-08-11 14:47:26
Updated At
2025-08-11 14:47:26

Caledon Bay

Type
Event

Details

Latitude
-12.796
Longitude
136.523
Start Date
1910-11-15
End Date
1910-11-20

Description

In November 1910, Aboriginal people reported that other Aboriginal people had murdered four European prospectors as well as a 'native and his lubra' in their employ. A party of 10 headed by Mounted Constables Kelly and Johns departed Roper River Police Station on 22 November to investigate. On 11 December, two Aboriginal men in custody were shot while escaping. Dewar (1992, p 8) noted: 'As late as 1910, the Love expedition resulted in a massacre where Police Constable Jim Kelly "had to shoot a couple of niggers" at Caledon Bay '(Love cited in Dewar 1992, p 8). George Conway, a participant in this massacre, told Keith Willey that "There were two policemen, two other white men, thirteen natives and myself in the team.... We were armed with rifles and revolvers and rode three hundred miles from the Roper across Arnhemland to Caledon Bay and back. The blacks attacked us every night. We had to shoot hundreds of them. Some of their camps contained two or three thousand people. We didn't shoot for the love of it, but because we had to kill or be killed.... They were rugged times all right" (van der Heide, 1985, p 85).

Extended Data

Source_ID
1018
LanguageGroup
Yolngu
Colony
SA
StateOrTerritory
NT
PoliceDistrict
Roper River
Victims
Colonists
VictimsDead
6
VictimDescription
Explorer(s), Servant(s)
Attackers
Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander People
AttackersDead
0
AttackerDescription
Aboriginal
CorroborationRating
***
War
Yolngu
Stage
Late
Region
North
Period
Late

Sources

TLCMap ID
te1738
Linkback
https://c21ch.newcastle.edu.au/colonialmassacres/detail.php?r=1018
Source
Dewar, 1992, p 8; NTTG, March 3, 1911, p 2 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article3266660; van der Heide, 1985, p 85.
Created At
2025-08-11 14:47:26
Updated At
2025-08-11 14:47:26

Birany Birany

Type
Event

Details

Latitude
-12.817
Longitude
136.477
Start Date
1911-01-01
End Date
1913-12-31

Description

Following the massacre at Gan Gan, Aboriginal people killed two colonists at Trial Bay. The attackers went to Trial Bay and then to Birany Birany where they massacred men, women and children again, though many escaped. He returned later to collect skulls. See also Gan Gan.
According to Galarrwuy Yunupingu, 'At Gan Gan these men on horseback performed their duties and killed an entire clan group ��� men, women and children. They shot them out and killed them in any way they could so that they could take the land. These men on horseback then rode to Birany Birany and killed many of our Yarrwidi Gumatj, the saltwater people who cared for the great ceremonies at Birany Birany. There are few places in our lives as sacred as Gan Gan ��� from its fresh waters all things come ��� and Birany Birany.' (Yunupingu, G 2016)
According to Bronwyn Wuyuwa Yunupingu, 'Again Harney came back. He went to Trial Bay, there our people killed two of his men. And after being at Trial Bay, he went to Biranybirany on the coast. There he and his men shot women gathering nuts But most people survived by running into the bush. And he went back, and the next year he came back for the skulls.' (Yunupingu, B p 15).
In the Preface to Bronwyn Wuyuwa Yunupingu A True, Bad Story Devlin wrote: 'The Bilayni or Bill Harney of this story is not to be confused with the man of the same name who was at one stage Protector of the Aborigines in the late 1940s and who later became an authority on Aboriginal matters'. Devlin said he had interviewed Birrikitji Gumana (the father of Gawirrin) who 'asserted without hesitation' that the Bilayni of the Gangan story 'came, murdered and was never seen again'. Using genealogical methods Devlin concluded the Gangan incident took place 'possibly a little before the war (1914-18)'. He therefore concluded that the Bilayni of the story was not the Bill Harney 'who was in the Gove area in 1946' (Yunupingu, B p i).
In the Preface to Bronwyn Wuyuwa Yunupingu A True, Bad Story Devlin wrote: 'The Bilayni or Bill Harney of this story is not to be confused with the man of the same name who was at one stage Protector of the Aborigines in the late 1940s and who later became an authority on Aboriginal matters'. Devlin said he had interviewed Birrikitji Gumana (the father of Gawirrin) who 'asserted without hesitation' that the Bilayni of the Gangan story 'came, murdered and was never seen again'. Using genealogical methods Devlin concluded the Gangan incident took place 'possibly a little before the war (1914-18)'. He therefore concluded that the Bilayni of the story was not the Bill Harney 'who was in the Gove area in 1946' (Yunupingu, B p i).
The events described indicate a high death toll, but that more escaped at Birany Birany, so the number of victims at Birany Birany may have been lower than at Gan Gan. Other massacres with recorded death tolls in this region and time, tend to average around 20 to 30. Warren Snowdon, when speaking of the death of Dr Gumana, said that, 'Dr Gumana spoke about a vengeance massacre of up to 30 of his people at Gangan when he was a young boy' (Snowdon, 2016). Galarrwuy Yunupingu said that 'an entire clan group' was killed and Bronwyn Wuyuwa Yunupingu indicated two groups were at the ceremony. The minimum size of a viable a clan group is about 20 (Mann, 2013 p 167-183) and they may be much larger. Since this was a large massacre, and there may have been two clan groups, 15 killed at Birany Birany is a conservative estimate.

Extended Data

Source_ID
932
LanguageGroup
Yolngu ��� Dhalwangu and Gumatj people
Colony
NT
StateOrTerritory
NT
PoliceDistrict
Darwin
Victims
Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander People
VictimsDead
15
Attackers
Colonists
AttackersDead
0
AttackerDescription
Mounted Police
CorroborationRating
**
AboriginalPlaceName
Birany Birany aka Gunyangara
War
Yolngu
Stage
Late
Region
North
Period
Late

Gan Gan

Type
Event

Details

Latitude
-13.046
Longitude
135.944
Start Date
1911-01-01
End Date
1913-12-31

Description

Men of two clan groups were at a men's ceremony, and women collecting food nearby were massacred at Gan Gan, killing almost everyone. Some were captured and some escaped. Following this Aboriginal people killed two colonists at Trial Bay. The attackers went to Trial Bay and then to Birany Birany where they massacred men, women and children again. They later returned to collect skulls for sale in southern cities. See also Birany Birany.
According to Galarrwuy Yunupingu, 'At Gan Gan these men on horseback performed their duties and killed an entire clan group ��� men, women and children. They shot them out and killed them in any way they could so that they could take the land. These men on horseback then rode to Birany Birany and killed many of our Yarrwidi Gumatj, the saltwater people who cared for the great ceremonies at Birany Birany. There are few places in our lives as sacred as Gan Gan ��� from its fresh waters all things come ��� and Birany Birany.' (Yunupingu, G 2016)
According to Bronwyn Wuyuwa Yunupingu men from two tribes were at a private ceremony site while the women and children collected food. 'None of them knew that a party of men with guns were riding towards the camp on horses. They were led by a man called Balayni also known as Bill Harney, a yella-fella from the Roper River area. The armed men band of men rode in to the camp and shot the older women.' (p4) The men saw their wives being shot and retaliated with spears but were driven back to a lagoon where some were shot and killed. Some children escaped and joined with some of the surviving men. Bill Harney's group captured other men women and children. She adds that, "This was not the end of the story though Bill Harney returned the next year and collected the skulls of the people he had murdered. And later sold them to a museum in southern cities and made a lot of money.'(Yunupingu, B p 13) Following this Yunupingu's people killed 2 or Harney's men at Trial Bay, and Bill Harney returned and massacred people at Birany Birany (Yunupingu, B p 15).
In the Preface to Bronwyn Wuyuwa Yunupingu A True, Bad Story Devlin wrote: 'The Bilayni or Bill Harney of this story is not to be confused with the man of the same name who was at one stage Protector of the Aborigines in the late 1940s and who later became an authority on Aboriginal matters'. Devlin said he had interviewed Birrikitji Gumana (the father of Gawirrin) who 'asserted without hesitation' that the Bilayni of the Gangan story 'came, murdered and was never seen again'. Using genealogical methods Devlin concluded the Gangan incident took place 'possibly a little before the war (1914-18)'. He therefore concluded that the Bilayni of the story was not the Bill Harney 'who was in the Gove area in 1946' (Yunupingu, B p i). The events described indicate a high death toll, but that more escaped at Birany Birany, so the number of victims at Birany Birany may have been lower than at Gan Gan. Other massacres with recorded death tolls in this region and time, tend to average around 20 to 30. Warren Snowdon, when speaking of the death of Dr Gumana, said that, 'Dr Gumana spoke about a vengeance massacre of up to 30 of his people at Gangan when he was a young boy' (Snowdon, 2016). Galarrwuy Yunupingu said that 'an entire clan group' was killed and Bronwyn Wuyuwa Yunupingu indicated two groups were at the ceremony. The minimum size of a viable a clan group is about 20 (Mann, 2013 p 167-183) and they may be much larger. Since this was a large massacre, and there may have been two clan groups, 25 killed at Gan Gan is a conservative estimate.

Extended Data

Source_ID
715
LanguageGroup
Yolngu ��� Dhalwangu and Gumatj people
Colony
NT
StateOrTerritory
NT
PoliceDistrict
Darwin
Victims
Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander People
VictimsDead
25
Attackers
Colonists
AttackersDead
0
AttackerDescription
Mounted Police
CorroborationRating
**
AboriginalPlaceName
Gangan
War
Yolngu
Stage
Late
Region
North
Period
Late
All Layers